Friday, February 17, 2017


The Senate has confirmed Trump's choice of Scott Pruitt as administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency.
What do Trump, Pruitt, and the John Birch Society have in common? A lot, it turns out.

Much of the logic used by climate change deniers follows a pattern also used by Evangelical Christians and "Creation Scientists," and those appear to have originated with the radically right John Birch Society.

You've heard of creation scientists, surely. They are the people who claim to use science to prove a model of an earth that is only five thousand years old, and in those five millennia, for example, humans were contemporaneous with dinosaurs. Some creation scientists also believe that the world is flat, and that the moon landings were cinematic productions staged by NASA in an abandoned warehouse somewhere.

The primary characteristic shared by creation scientists and climate change deniers is a particularly militant form of wishful thinking. That is, my beliefs are cast in bedrock certainty, so any science that contradicts them is not only false but suspect. Oftentimes these falsehoods are explained as conspiracies, which is a methodology that dates all the way back to the John Birch Society, an organization for which KKK members hung up their sheets and put on business suits. The John Birch Society invented many of the techniques for denying inconvenient truths that conflict with beliefs carved in stone. The concept of fake news as a way of dismissing inconvenient truths began with the Birchers, and they were always quick to add that Walter Cronkite's name came from the German krankheit, meaning sickness. Apparently these homonyms served as proof of some conspiracy to hoodwink the public.

Speaking of significant homonyms, the commonly used short name for the Society is (or was) Birchers, and I always found the near homonyms of Birchers and Birthers to be an interesting coincidence if not an outright name tag to say, "We're still here."

A lot of the nonsensical extremism was tamed out of the conservative movement by William F Buckley, who took a very rational, educated, and level-headed view of the issues, which he discussed in his magazine, The National Review, on his PBS talk show, Firing Line, and in numerous books. Buckley, who had a Yale education and a distinctively Yankee accent fired by a blast furnace intellect, was inaccessible to those whose intellect does not and cannot extend far beyond wishful thinking. In the South, where the poorest, least educated, and most openly racist states congregate, wishes rise over reality, and a passion for a tough love Messianic politician who will exorcise America's demons. Tyrants depend upon internal enemies for scapegoats—Hitler's Jews, for example. The great leader will name the enemy responsible for all our problems and circumscribe him. The leader will restore a Great Nation that, rather like a Brigadoon, is hopelessly buried in a mythical past. The South loves the great leader, but they also protest vociferously against his opposition, The irony lies in the opposition's bearing policies from which they would most benefit, but down South they paradoxically support the policies of the rich at the expense of the poor.

Trump's use of many of the tactics that originated with the John Birch Society suggests that, yes, indeed, they're still here. Claims of fake news, a vast Weltanschauung constructed wholly of conspiracy theories, lies contrived from spontaneously manufactured factoids, the ever-present undercurrent of hate and anger, the exclusive white male power enclave, and the ascendancy of belief over truth, all spell out the John Birch Society—or something worse.

Evangelical churches and colleges offering education in creation science form the religious arm of ultra-right culture, and the three branches—fundamentalist churches, their colleges, and ultra-right wing political organizations—serve the same segment of the population. So it's really quite sad that Scott Pruitt, Oklahoma's attorney general and an Evangelical Christian and Creationist has been confirmed by the Senate as the administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency. He will serve as a curator of the agency's assets while the Trump administration dismantles the agency. Industry will soon be free to pollute for profit. Trump has already signed executive orders to begin the dismantling, but Congress will have some say in the matter.

Conservatism is really a populist rhetoric to gain public support for policies that benefit only extremely wealthy people. Even before the world falls apart, most jobs will be automated, so unemployment will be massive, but the rich will enjoy higher profits than ever before because they no longer pay the wages that were once their biggest expense. But behind unemployment and hunger looms the spirit of revolution.

The poverty documented in mid-19th-century novels like Les Miserables, David Copperfield, and Crime and Punishment explains why Marx, who was writing at the same time, believed that a workers' revolution was inevitable. But for liberal reforms like those of the Fabian Society in Britain, Marx may have been right about historical inevitability. The Czar and his wife were so out of touch with the reality outside palace walls that they took no preventive measures except to send brigades of soldiers with bayonets into crowds of hungry protesters, so the revolution was indeed inevitable in Russia. And maybe as automation drives unemployment insufferably high in the US, the rich might throw out a sop of guaranteed basic income lest they suffer similar consequences.

However, once the climate becomes unbearably hot, the rich will still afford their air conditioning. Once food becomes so scarce that we either fight with the gang controlling the local supermarket or starve, they will have larders brimming with food. Once our society at large becomes a post-apocalyptic dog-eat-dog chaos, they will live safely behind unbreachable walls. Governments by, of, and for the rich hasten the day.